Logo

Debate continues over Chinese balloon shot down by US military

Debate continues over Chinese balloon shot down by US military

2023-02-08

And talk continues about the Chinese spy balloon that was shot down by the U.S. four days ago. China insists that the object was a civilian balloon used mainly for meteorological purposes. But suspicions remain that it was actually used for espionage. A surge in publications in recent years shows that China has been very interested in military applications for balloons.

This video appears to show the U.S. military shooting down a Chinese balloon that had entered U.S. airspace. The U.S. Navy has since released photos of the balloon’s debris. Commenting on the incident, Japan said it will do the same if necessary in the future.

Hamada Yasukazu
Japanese minister of defense
If there is a need to do such a thing to protect lives and property, it will be done.

The Japanese defense ministry says it will change its approach from that of three years ago, when a balloon was spotted drifting in several areas of the country. China insists that the balloon that was shot down was used for “mainly meteorological” purposes, and was not a military aircraft. The claims have been received with suspicion, as publications from recent years show China’s growing interest in military applications for balloons.

A report from April 2022 focusing on the military use of high-altitude balloons mentions that the technology can be used in different battle scenarios. For example, releasing a large number of balloons can be used to monitor the enemy’s early-warning systems, and wear out enemy air defenses. There are also publications stating that loading balloons with explosives could pose a threat at ground level even if they are shot down. Analysts say China has been thoroughly researching the technology and its military applications.

Wang Zhin-sheng
Association of Chinese Elite Leadership
The question is not whether it was a military or a civilian balloon. The question is whether that kind of balloon can be used for military operations such as collecting intelligence and espionage. Even if it were a civilian balloon, it still could be used for military operations. China says that it was a civilian balloon, and that it had nothing to do with the military. But that argument doesn’t stand. China is a communist totalitarian country, as such nothing is truly civilian.

The balloon has further raised tensions between the U.S. and China, which could only get worse if it is determined that the balloon was being used for military purposes.

中國堅稱氣球氣象用 慘遭自家文獻打臉

2023-02-08

中國間諜氣球闖入美國領空,遭美軍擊落,引發後續極大風波,中方堅稱這是氣象科研使用,卻被翻出的文獻狠狠打臉,因為內容提到氣球可達成監視敵方預警系統、疲憊騷擾空防體系等目的,且不論是地面防空武器還是空中力量,都很難攔截、擊毀,甚至提出未來可運用於戰場的對策,戳破北京謊言。

疑似美國軍方打下中國間諜氣球的影片流出,美國海軍也公布氣球殘骸的最新照片,看到美國擊落,日本也表明態度。

[[日本防衛大臣 濱田靖一]]
“為了守護生命財產,如果有必要這麼做,將會如此實施(擊落氣球)。”

日本防衛省強調未來若有需要,不會再重演三年前,放任中國間諜氣球四處飄的局面。雖然中國堅持這只是「氣象科研」,與軍事無關,但近來有論文與文獻被翻出,寫到空飄球在軍事上的運用。

[[解放軍論文轉場]]

這篇在去年四月,以「空飄球在軍事對抗中的運用」為題的文章,提到氣球在軍事上根據不同作戰任務,大規模施放可達成監視敵對方預警系統、疲憊騷擾空防體系等作戰目的,而且若氣球載有炸彈,即使擊中也會對地面構成威脅,類似文獻還有不少,顯示解放軍早已對氣球用在戰場,做了深入研究。

[[中華亞太菁英交流協會秘書長 王智盛]]
“問題不在軍用、民用,問題在於這樣的氣球,能不能進行相關的情蒐、間諜等軍事用途。即便是民用狀況,都能夠轉為軍事用途。中國講說這是民用氣球,不關軍事用途的說法不攻自破。中國是共產極權的國家,並沒有真正民用。”

氣球侵門踏戶,已讓美中降到冰點,若最後證實是軍事用,兩國關係恐怕真的回不去了。

Related News

Taiwan rushes to help Turkey with donations and search and rescue teams

2023-02-08

Taiwan center in southern Turkey provides shelter to hundreds of locals

2023-02-08

High-calorie, high-protein diet is the key to living happily with dialysis: doctors

2023-02-08

KMT vice chair sets off for 10-day China visit including meeting with TAO head

2023-02-08

Turkey earthquake more powerful than 1999 Jiji earthquake: seismologists

2023-02-08

A tooth with small cracks can be split open by a mere guava: dentists

2023-02-08

Filipino artist Marina Cruz depicts memories of a flood-swept childhood in Bulacan

2023-02-08