Logo

Rankings of top Taiwan universities drop with only 3 remaining in world’s top 100

Rankings of top Taiwan universities drop with only 3 remaining in world’s top 100

2023-06-25

The 2023 rankings of nearly 1,800 universities around the globe by the Times Higher Education magazine have come out, and Taiwan did not get a high score. Only three of Taiwan’s top universities are in the top 100, and two of the three, National Taiwan University and National Tsing Hua University, have seen their positions drop significantly over the past 10 years. Some are worried that Taiwan’s top students will decide to study abroad instead of staying in the country to pursue higher learning.

In the category of Asia University Rankings under the Times Higher Education World University Rankings, National Taiwan University has dropped from last year’s 21st place down to its current 29th place.

Hsu Kuan-tse
NTU graduate student association
If we look at it in a positive light, this indicator can certainly help us understand the performance of various universities around the world with various quantitative data. But these statistics also have their limitations. The indicators may not be able to reflect the value that universities have in promoting social progress.

Not just NTU, but National Yang Ming Chiao Tung University is now at 85th place, National Tsing Hua University at 95th, and National Cheng Kung University has dropped out of the top 100, landing at 159th place. The rankings of Taiwan’s top universities have all gone south, reflecting the woes in local higher education.

Huang I-chang
USC supply chain management graduate student
I think there are more opportunities overseas, so you’re not confined to Taiwan. Another reason for going abroad is that it can be used as a springboard, so that you can have work opportunities in America.

Tsai Wei-an
Harvard Law School student
I want to better understand Taiwan, and I want to put it in a larger structure and in a bigger map, so I can see it more clearly. I also want to know other people’s views and how they see Taiwan. That’s why I decided to leave Taiwan, so the ranking was not a deciding factor for me.

Many Taiwanese students who study abroad say that the bigger job market and the more liberal environment overseas are the reasons behind their decision to study abroad, and that university rankings are not so important. So why have Taiwan’s universities fallen behind others? Experts say that unlike the top institutions overseas, Taiwan’s universities cater mostly to undergraduates and lack graduate students who conduct research. This has led to the less-than-stellar evaluations of their research capacities.

Huang I-chang
USC supply chain management graduate student
Before I came abroad, I thought university rankings were very important, but after I came here, I realized that the rankings, especially the overall rankings, are not that important. I don’t think the drop in rankings will have much impact on students studying in Taiwan.

Tsai Wei-an
Harvard Law School student
They should try and create an open atmosphere within their limited resources there in Taiwan, so that foreign students with various backgrounds would be willing to go there, and even Taiwan’s own minority groups would be willing to stay there for study.

National Taiwan University has responded that it would continue to work hard to make improvements. It said it would advocate that the evaluation of universities should not only be based on the number of research papers produced and how much influence those papers have. Evaluations should also be based on a school’s efforts toward talent cultivation, teaching and research, as well as the contributions of its alumni to society.


亞洲大學排行 台大29名、清大95排名皆下滑

2023-06-25

泰晤士高等教育特刊,公布2023亞洲大學排名,台大又再度下滑,從去年的21名,退到29名。而國內頂大,入選百大的,只有台大、陽交大跟清大,但台大與清大兩所學校在十年內,都大退步。清大更是差點跌出百名,只有95名。也讓人擔心,是否會衝擊台灣高教,留不住頂尖學生。

根據泰晤士高等教育特刊,公布的2023亞洲大學排名,台大從去年的21名,退到29名。

[[台大研究生協會長 許冠澤]]
“如果是正面來看,我們確實可以用這個指標,來去了解全世界各個大學,他們現在在各種量化數據上的表現。這個指標統計項目也有一定侷限性,這些指標都不一定能夠反應,現在大學所帶給我們推動社會進步的價值。”

不只台大,年年下滑,陽明交通大學名列85、清大排在95名,成大更是掉出百名,位居159。頂大普遍持續下滑,凸顯高等教育的困境。

[[南加州大學供應鏈管理碩士生 黃奕昌]]
“我覺得出國有更多的機會,就不會只侷限於台灣,再來是出國另外一個原因是可以當作跳板,就可以在美國職場,有機會發展。”

[[哈佛大學法學博士生 蔡惟安]]
“我想了解台灣,要把它放在更大的架構裡面,更大的地圖裡面,我會看得更清楚,所以我想要知道別人的觀點,想知道別人是怎麼理解台灣的,所以我才選擇出來,所以排名對我來說是沒有決定性的。”

國外留學生多半認為,更大的就業市場及更開放的環境,是吸引他們出國的主要因素,大學排名並不重要。但為何台灣大學排名,節節敗退,專家認為,國內不像國外頂尖大學,學士班學生太多,有研究能力的碩博士生太少,因此在研究評比上才會落後。

[[南加州大學供應鏈管理碩士生 黃奕昌]]
“我出國以前會覺得大學排名很重要,但我在出國後我會發現,其實排名尤其是總排名,沒有那麼的重要,排名往後我覺得對在台灣讀書的學生不會有太多的影響。”

[[哈佛大學法學博士生 蔡惟安]]
“盡可能在有限資源內,創造出開放的氣氛,讓外國學生願意來,各種不同多元背景,甚至台灣自己的少數族群願意來(就讀)。”

台大回應,會持續努力精進,主張衡量大學,不能只看論文產出數及影響力,還要看人才培育教研,及校友對社會的貢獻度。

Related News

China’s military flies eight sorties within 44 kilometers of Taiwan proper

2023-06-25

Californian couple opens vegan restaurant in Taiwan

2023-06-25

Spotlight on cross-cultural artist couple Chiu Chieh-sen and Margot Guillemot

2023-06-25